Justice Minister Sean Fraser suggested yesterday that the International Criminal Court’s (ICC) arrest warrant against Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu only applies if he actually lands in Canada — and not when he flies through Canadian airspace.
Netanyahu, who led Israel’s ongoing genocide in Gaza, along with former Israeli defence minister Yoav Gallant, were subject to the ICC warrants in November 2024. They are accused of committing a long list of serious war crimes against Palestinian civilians.
Despite this, Canada has repeatedly allowed Netanyahu to fly through Canadian airspace while en route to the United States. Critics have argued that Canada’s decision to allow this undermines the authority of the court, which the Liberal government claims to support.
When asked about this by The Maple at the Halifax International Security Forum, Fraser said “the defence of the institution goes beyond any one order that they may issue,” before repeating concerns about the U.S. government’s imposition of sanctions on ICC judges, including Canadian judge Kim Prost.
Prost was specifically targeted by the Trump regime last year for authorizing an ICC investigation into alleged crimes committed by American military personnel in Afghanistan.
“I don’t see there to be a cognitive dissonance between willingness to execute the warrants on Canadian soil and our continued political support in public for the operations of the institution as a body that must work independently of the political decisions of its state parties,” said Fraser.
“Should we have the opportunity to execute our warrants for individuals on Canadian soil, we wouldn’t be afraid to do so.”
Prime Minister Mark Carney’s office made a similar suggestion in July when it told CBC News: “Canada does not currently link its overflight policy to law enforcement objectives except where an imminent security risk is present.”
In September, however, Foreign Affairs Minister Anita Anand indicated that her department was less certain about whether Canada had any enforcement obligations in its airspace.
When asked about Netanyahu’s flight to the United Nations that month, she told reporters: “I actually have asked my department to provide me with information relating to this particular flyover.”
The Israeli prime minister was ultimately allowed to fly over Canada and has also been permitted to fly over several European countries that are also ICC members.
The claim that the ICC, which is governed by the Rome Statue, only requires its arrest warrants to be enforced on the soil of member states is hotly contested by international legal experts.
Writing for Justice In Conflict in July, Mark Kersten, an assistant professor of criminology and criminal justice who has written a book about the ICC, explained:
“Nothing in the Rome Statute suggests the drafters sought to define ‘territory’ to the exclusion of coastal waters and airspace. And we know that, by law, state sovereignty exercised over territory extends further than just its landmass and includes coastal waters as well the air above.”
“The airspace above a state is [a] core part of the area over which a state exercises territorial sovereignty.”
